The TrekEarth Forums

The TrekEarth Forums (
-   Announcements (
-   -   Gold Star Critiquers (

adam 10-20-2002 10:04 AM

Gold Star Critiquers
To recognize those members who leave useful critiques, a Gold Star icon will be displayed next to members who receive many 'useful' critiques and a minimum of 'not useful' critiques. Please mark fellow member critiques as either 'useful' or 'not useful' if you feel it's warranted.

mdchachi 10-20-2002 05:39 PM

Re: Gold Star Critiquers
What is your criteria for rating critiques as useful? I find myself tempted to give "useful" marks to praise of my photos even when the remark isn't particularly useful.

adam 10-20-2002 07:55 PM

Re: Gold Star Critiquers
The criteria is whether another member rates a critique as 'useful'. That a member who receives a positive critique, ie 'Excellent shot!' should want to return the favor by marking it as 'useful' is fairly natural. This is why it's important for other members to mark critiques either useful or not useful for critiques not involving their own photos. This will more than cancel out the effect of the situation you describe. Also, the critiquer cannot see that you rated them as useful/not useful so it's better to be honest about it anyway.

anindya2u 11-19-2009 03:35 AM

Re: Gold Star Critiquers
How user points (as against the critique points) is related to the Gold or Silver symbol beside member's name.
I saw a member getting (94) point is a Gold Critiquer but a member having (132) point is still not getting the same?

bmukherjee 12-23-2009 01:10 AM

Re: Gold Star Critiquers

Here's how the system works: the user points next to the user name are the sum of useful points and photo points. You get 2 photo points when someone gives you a green smiley - these points are unrelated to the gold symbols.

You get 1 useful point if someone marks your note/workshop/critique useful. If your accumulated useful points in any of the those categories is over 10, you get a silver icon; over 50, it becomes gold-coloured.

Most TE members will agree that the point system is only for encouraging: some even find it distracting... I think it helps introducing new TE members to the TE system...


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:09 AM.

Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.